Subscribe to the BioNews newsletter for free

Advanced Search

Search for

Like the Progress Educational Trust on Facebook



High Court rejects fertility clinic challenge to HFEA website

24 April 2017

By Antony Blackburn-Starza

Appeared in BioNews 897

A claim for judicial review that sought to challenge changes to the way the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) presents data about UK fertility clinics on its website has failed.

Following a consultation exercise last year and a recommendation in the McCracken Report in 2013, the HFEA decided in November to make changes to the way it presents data about fertility clinics on the 'Choose a Fertility Clinic' section of its website, which is viewed by around 1500 people every month.

The Assisted Reproduction and Gynaecology Centre (ARGC), a London fertility clinic, argued that the decisions to change the data presentation were unlawful on the grounds that the proposed presentation of the data was 'illogical, potentially misleading and unreasonable' and went against the HFEA's legal obligations to provide information, advice and transparency. It also argued that the decisions were made without proper consultation and that the HFEA failed to take into account the views and preferences of patients given in the consultation.

The changes include basing the new 'headline IVF birth rate' on each clinic profile on all patients under 38 years old (it is currently expressed for patients under 37 years old and then also for patients aged 35-37) and changing the presentation of the IVF success rate from six to three age categories: patients under 38, those over 38 and one for all patients.

The HFEA also decided to use the live birth rate 'per embryo transferred' in the expression of IVF success rate and not the birth rate 'per treatment cycle'. Not all patients will reach the egg collection stage or embryo transfer stage after starting the IVF cycle. The HFEA's consultation indicated that patients preferred success data by 'live birth rate per cycle started', whereas clinicians favoured 'per embryo transfer' as the most meaningful measure of success.

Hearing the application, Ms Justice Finola O'Farrell pointed out that the ARGC has had the highest pregnancy and live birth rate since its establishment, but since it treats a higher proportion of older patients and patients with previously unsuccessful IVF it is more likely to transfer more than one embryo per cycle. As such, she said, 'The decisions by the HFEA will have an adverse impact on the success rates shown on its clinic profile page'.

Nevertheless, the judge held the HFEA was entitled to change the metric it uses: 'There is no single measure of IVF success that has universal support or acceptance ... It is not for this court to decide whether either metric, neither or both should be used as headline figures. This court must consider whether the HFEA's decision was within the range of reasonable decisions open to it in all the circumstances,' she said – and in this case, the decision was not outside this range.


08 May 2017 - by Shaoni Bhattacharya 
The UK's fertility regulator, the HFEA, says it will be investigating a series of allegations concerning the fertility industry made by the Daily Mail newspaper last week...

09 January 2017 - by Ayala Ochert 
Implanting two embryos can reduce IVF success by a quarter if one of the embryos is of poorer quality, new research suggests...
21 November 2016 - by Antony Blackburn-Starza 
An online calculator that can estimate the cumulative success rate of IVF over multiple cycles has been released...
04 April 2016 - by Antony Blackburn-Starza 
Pregnancy and live birth rates following IVF have continued to increase as the multiple-birth rate declines, according to the latest figures released by the HFEA...
15 November 2013 - by Antony Blackburn-Starza 
The UK's High Court has ruled against the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority saying its actions towards two clinics over a licence condition to impose a maximum multiple birth rate were unlawful. The HFEA has now decided to withdraw the condition from all UK fertility clinics' licences...
22 July 2013 - by Cait McDonagh 
The Department of Health has announced that the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority will remain the independent regulator of assisted reproduction and embryology research in the UK...

Be the first to have your say.

You need to or  to add comments.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

- click here to enquire about using this story.

Published by the Progress Educational Trust


Public Conference
8 December 2017

Speakers include

Professor Azim Surani

Professor Magdalena Zernicka-Goetz

Professor Robin Lovell-Badge

Sally Cheshire

Professor Guido Pennings

Katherine Littler

Professor Allan Pacey

Dr Sue Avery

Professor Richard Anderson

Dr Elizabeth Garner

Dr Andy Greenfield

Dr Anna Smajdor

Dr Henry Malter

Vivienne Parry

Dr Helen O'Neill

Dr César Palacios-González

Philippa Taylor

Fiona Fox

Sarah Norcross

Sandy Starr


Good Fundraising Code

Become a Friend of PET HERE and give the Progress Educational Trust a regular donation