16 July 2012
ByAppeared in BioNews 665
BBC News Health, Thursday 21 June 2012
Presented by Dr Dusko Ilic
As a viewer I do not ask for much from a show; just to be a little informative, maybe some whimsical anecdote - unfortunately I did not even get this from this short film. Instead, what I got was two and a half minutes of footage mostly of people opening doors and looking 'sciency' to weird music.
This short video is called 'How to make stem cells' but a more accurate title might have been 'Where to make stem cells'. The film did not explain what stem cells are, or why a line of stem cells is needed. It is just a tour looking at people who are looking through microscopes. Don't get me wrong, the funky sci-fi themed music really built up some atmosphere. But the commentary, which includes a run-through of the clothing worn in the lab, left a lot to be desired. Unless the intention was to make Guy's Hospital look like the medical fashion capital of the world - watch out Paris and Milan!
Dr Dusko Ilic from the Assisted Conception Unit at Guy's Hospital, London gave the briefest of explanations of how stem cells could be used in the treatment of heart disease and diabetes followed by an awkward ending in which Dr Illic and a colleague (in full white overalls) staring longingly into the camera before they walk through yet another door (for no obvious reason), before the film ends.
I am possibly being too harsh - there were elements of interesting scientific fact, including that embryos used in research at the clinic were donated following IVF and the description of how a colony of stem cells grows. But these were washed away by the sheer agony of viewing the film. I am all for using new media and accessible formats to engage the public about the sometimes misunderstood area of stem cell research. I am just not convinced that this formant really worked this time.