Subscribe to the BioNews newsletter for free

Login
Advanced Search

Search for
BioNews

Like the Progress Educational Trust on Facebook


 


 

TV Review: Postcode Lottery

12 March 2012

By Cathy Holding

Appeared in BioNews 648

Postcode Lottery

BBC1, Thursday 8 March 2012

Presented by Dominic Littlewood

'Postcode Lottery', BBC1, Thursday 8 March 2012


BBC1's 8 March episode of 'Postcode Lottery', presented by Dominic Littlewood, featured Sarah and Levi Johnson, a couple living in Portsmouth who want to have IVF on the NHS.

After six unsuccessful years of trying to conceive naturally, they discovered, to their dismay, they fall foul of the strict qualifying criteria set by their local PCT. Sarah is now too old (over 35) and too overweight [BMI (body mass index) above 30], and her partner Levi has a child from a previous relationship – all three are no-gos for a couple wanting IVF on the NHS in this area.

Sarah has polycystic ovaries, endometriosis and fibrosis, and was told by her fertility consultant that nothing more could be done for her – unless she had £5000 for private IVF treatment. 'That was the end of anybody doing anything for us', she said.

The couple described their situation as 'devastating' and 'heart-breaking'. Levi said it was impossible to imagine the pain Sarah felt after having been told, as he put it, 'you can't have children, that's it, go away'.

The fact IVF was pioneered in this country featured prominently in the programme. 'How is it', demanded Littlewood, 'that in a nation of medical miracles and bouncing babies, thousands more women are being denied access to this potentially life-changing treatment?'

However, he quoted statistics saying that there had been 12,714 IVF births in 2009, and that over 45,000 more women in the UK received IVF treatment in 2010. To me, this figure is astonishing – and suggests quite a lot of women are actually successfully gaining access to IVF on the NHS.

According to the programme, the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence recommendations for couples seeking IVF treatment on the NHS are three free cycles of treatment to women between the ages of 23 and 39. However, each PCT is allowed to set their own criteria based on the likelihood of a woman conceiving by IVF.

As the programme title suggests, the focus was on the differences in PCT criteria according to postcode. For example, women in Portsmouth must be under 35, whereas in Brighton they can be up to 39. In the Midlands, most PCTs have a maximum age policy for the male partner. Finally, according to the programme, NHS Surrey only offer IVF at the age of 39 – 'not a year younger, not a year older!' says Littlewood. (However, as reported in BioNews 633, as of April 2012, IVF on the NHS will be reinstated in Surrey).

The number of children from previous relationships also differs depending on area: in Portsmouth it's zero; in Bolton one partner is allowed one child; and in Hackney you are allowed four children from previous relationships, as long as you have none with your current partner.

For me, the main issue this programme raised was the arbitrary variations that people get caught up in because of different criteria set by individual PCTs.

Furthermore, I felt the programme was trying to imply that every couple should be given the chance to try IVF because of its miraculous, life-changing abilities. But IVF is only miraculous and life-changing if it works.

While the success rate for IVF (25 percent) was given by Littlewood, along with the acknowledgement that this 'falls sharply over the age of 35', he buried these statistics in an attack on NHS Surrey for only offering IVF at the age of 39.

So IVF is, in itself, very much a lottery. But if you don't play then you can't win.

Meanwhile, Sarah and Levi both appear to believe bureaucracy is the only thing standing in the way of a pregnancy.

In her closing comment she said: 'There is somebody out there who can help us, and so I'll just keep fighting – until eventually I get my child'.

And indeed she is fighting, in March 2011, Sarah started an online petition calling for IVF criteria to be made uniform across the UK. She aims to reach a thousand signatures before presenting it to Downing Street (1).

Levi summed up their feelings: 'Just one child, it's not a lot to ask for, is it?'

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Go Petition | 14 March 2011
 

RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE

10 December 2012 - by Ari Haque 
A couple who was refused fertility treatment on the NHS for being 'too old' has said it intends to challenge the decision in the courts, arguing that the decision amounts to age discrimination....
02 July 2012 - by Louisa Ghevaert 
The inconsistent and inadequate provision of IVF treatment on the NHS is an unacceptable way to treat the one in seven UK couples (3.5 million people) currently affected by infertility...
30 April 2012 - by Annabel Christie 
Following the investigation of abortion clinics, fertility clinics should now improve their procedures so that there are no unwanted surprises if they are similarly inspected...

14 November 2011 - by Dr Kimberley Bryon-Dodd 
NHS Surrey will reinstate free IVF treatment on 1 April 2012, following a year's suspension to cut costs...
15 August 2011 - by Susan Seenan 
Thirty years after the birth of the first IVF baby, you would expect the country that pioneered the technique to lead the world in providing access to fertility treatment. At the very least, the UK would guarantee fair and equitable access for eligible patients. But you would be wrong. Patients across the country are still fighting to get the treatment they deserve...
08 August 2011 - by Dr Anna Smajdor 
In 2007, the world's media reported - with various degrees of shock and disapproval - on a Big Brother-style TV programme being created in Holland. This was Big Brother with a bizarre twist: instead of a cash prize and a moment of minor celebrity, the winner would get ... a kidney. Fast forward to 2011. A similar media outcry has been provoked by the announcement by fertility charity To Hatch of a lottery where the prize is - not cash; not a kidney, but... fertility treatment...
13 June 2011 - by Gareth Johnson MP 
IVF is one of Britain's greatest inventions. Professor Robert Edwards received the Nobel Prize for Medicine for his pioneering work developing this fertility treatment and - in the last week - it has been announced that he will be knighted in the Queen's Birthday Honours list. The result of Professor Edward's work was Louise Brown, the world's first so-called 'test tube' baby. Britain, more than any other country, should be championing the use of IVF treatment...
28 February 2011 - by Ayesha Ahmad 
A survey by Pulse, a weekly magazine aimed at General Practitioners (GPs), has revealed that 31 percent of GPs report that their patients are facing restrictions in IVF treatment following the latest cost-saving measures...

HAVE YOUR SAY
Be the first to have your say.

You need to or  to add comments.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


- click here to enquire about using this story.

Published by the Progress Educational Trust

CROSSING FRONTIERS

Public Conference
London
8 December 2017

Speakers include

Professor Azim Surani

Professor Magdalena Zernicka-Goetz

Professor Robin Lovell-Badge

Sally Cheshire

Professor Guido Pennings

Katherine Littler

Professor Allan Pacey

Dr Sue Avery

Professor Richard Anderson

Dr Elizabeth Garner

Dr Andy Greenfield

Dr Anna Smajdor

Dr Henry Malter

Vivienne Parry

Dr Helen O'Neill

Dr César Palacios-González

Philippa Taylor

Fiona Fox

Sarah Norcross

Sandy Starr


BOOK HERE

Good Fundraising Code

Become a Friend of PET HERE and give the Progress Educational Trust a regular donation